Whether you're a seasoned numismatist or just beginning your journey into coin collecting, finding a trustworthy and reputable coin dealership is essential. With countless options across the United States, it can be overwhelming to determine which dealers offer authenticity, fair pricing, and exceptional customer service. This guide highlights the top 10 coin dealerships in the USA—carefully selected based on reputation, product variety, customer feedback, and service quality.
To make your search easier, we’ve divided the list into two categories: offline (brick-and-mortar) dealerships and online coin dealers. Each option offers unique benefits depending on your preferences—whether you value in-person appraisals or the convenience of digital shopping.
Offline Coin Dealerships
These physical locations provide face-to-face interactions, immediate transactions, and professional coin appraisals. Many also offer walk-in services and accept various payment methods, including credit cards and even cryptocurrency.
Oxbridge Coins – San Francisco, CA
Established in 1990, Oxbridge Coins has built a strong reputation for integrity and expertise. Located in the heart of San Francisco, this dealership welcomes walk-ins but recommends appointments for faster service.
Key features:
- Free, no-obligation coin appraisals
- Accepts cryptocurrency and credit cards
- Knowledgeable staff with years of experience
Address: 2115 Van Ness Ave, San Francisco, CA 94109
Phone: (415) 409-6086
Open: Monday through Saturday
👉 Discover how top-rated dealers like Oxbridge Coins ensure authentic coin investments.
"Truly gentleman. I’m sure some of the coins we took in were…….less than stellar, but there was no judgment. We were given fair trade on our transaction. This is the place." – Keith D.
Viera Coins & Collectibles – Elmhurst, NY
Since 2005, Viera Coins has served collectors and investors in Queens, New York. The owner is fluent in English, Spanish, and Portuguese, making communication accessible for a diverse clientele.
Highlights:
- Specializes in U.S. and international coins and paper currency
- Accepts Apple Pay and credit cards
- Personalized attention from owner-operator
Address: 86-55 Broadway Store A9, Elmhurst, NY 11373
Phone: (718) 255-1866
Open: Monday through Saturday
"He runs the place by himself, so hours can be tricky... but he is very accommodating to everyone who waits when he does." – Dana R.
National Rare Coins and Estate Buyers – Hollywood, FL
Operating since 1985, this Florida-based shop specializes in rare coins and estate purchases. Known for transparency and fairness, they serve both individual collectors and businesses.
Features:
- Bilingual service (English and Spanish)
- Walk-ins accepted; appointments preferred
- Trusted source for buying and selling rare coins
Address: 4000 Hollywood Blvd, Suite #155, Hollywood, FL 33021
Phone: (954) 963-0101
Open: Monday through Friday
"They always give me the best price on the spot, and when I purchase, they never gouge." – Nicholas L.
Rocklin Coin Shop – Rocklin, CA
Founded in 2009, Rocklin Coin Shop offers a welcoming environment for new and experienced collectors alike. Friendly staff and professional service make it a favorite among Northern California residents.
Perks:
- Credit card payments accepted
- Family-friendly atmosphere
- Great for educational visits
Address: 4870 Granite Dr, Rocklin, CA 95677
Phone: (916) 315-0888
Open: Monday through Saturday
"Matthew and Ariana were accommodating, professional, and friendly. They made me feel welcome." – Larry L.
U.S. Coins & Jewelry – Houston, TX
A long-standing name in the industry since 1985, this Houston dealership combines coin trading with jewelry services. They emphasize fair market value and customer satisfaction.
Benefits:
- Price-beat or price-match guarantee
- Free appraisals without obligation
- Strong focus on customer education
Address: 8435 Katy Freeway, Houston, TX 77024
Phone: (713) 597-6367
Open: Monday through Saturday
"They try to work with the customer—that’s good customer service." – R G.
Bonanza Coins – Silver Spring, MD
With roots dating back to 1961, Bonanza Coins has become a trusted name in Maryland’s numismatic community. Owner Julian brings decades of experience to every interaction.
Why choose Bonanza Coins?
- Accepts cryptocurrency payments
- Open seven days a week (Sunday by appointment)
- Expert guidance for beginners
Address: 940 Wayne Avenue, Silver Spring, MD 20910
Phone: (301) 585-8467
Open: Monday–Saturday; Sunday by appointment
"The owner Julian was knowledgeable and helpful when asking my questions about my Peace Dollar." – David S.
Old Pueblo Coin – Tucson, AZ
Established in 1982, Old Pueblo Coin serves Arizona collectors with honesty and professionalism. Whether selling a single gold coin or an entire collection, clients appreciate their straightforward approach.
Notable services:
- Free appraisals
- On-site authenticity testing
- Cash payouts for precious metals
Address: 4255 E. Speedway Blvd, Tucson, AZ 85712
Phone: (520) 881-7200
Open: Monday through Saturday
"I felt I got a fair share... they need to make a profit buying and selling." – Alex C.
Online Coin Dealerships
For those who prefer shopping from home or accessing national inventory, online dealers offer convenience, competitive pricing, and secure shipping.
Money Metal Exchange
One of the most respected names in online bullion sales, Money Metal Exchange provides high-quality coins at transparent prices.
Top advantages:
- Wide selection of gold and silver coins
- Free shipping on orders over $500
- Monthly savings plan for consistent investing
- Prepackaged starter kits for new investors
"Their prices are competitive with minimal premium… packages are very sturdy and unmarked." – Jim S.
👉 See how verified online dealers streamline secure coin investing.
Golden Eagle Coins
Founded in 1974, Golden Eagle Coins boasts an extensive catalog of gold investment coins and numismatic rarities.
What sets them apart:
- Over 50 years in business
- Seven-day return policy
- Excellent customer support
- Long-standing online reputation
"I called, and a lovely woman on the phone upgraded some of the coins… very cool!" – SSG Rocker
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What should I look for in a reputable coin dealership?
A: Look for dealers with transparent pricing, authentication processes, positive customer reviews, and clear return policies. Membership in organizations like the ANA (American Numismatic Association) is also a strong indicator of credibility.
Q: Are online coin dealers safe?
A: Yes—reputable online dealers use encrypted websites, insured shipping, and offer buyback programs. Always check third-party reviews and BBB ratings before purchasing.
Q: Can I sell my old coins for more than face value?
A: It depends on rarity, condition, metal content, and demand. Most circulated coins are worth face value unless they contain silver or gold or are collectible editions.
Q: Do coin dealers accept cryptocurrency?
A: Some do—dealers like Oxbridge Coins and Bonanza Coins accept Bitcoin and other digital currencies as payment for precious metal coins.
Q: Should I get my coins appraised before selling?
A: Yes. A professional appraisal helps determine true market value and protects against underpayment. Many top dealers offer free evaluations.
👉 Learn how trusted platforms verify authenticity before every transaction.
Final Thoughts
Whether you're buying your first silver dollar or liquidating a family collection, choosing a reliable coin dealership ensures confidence in every transaction. From local shops offering personalized service to online giants with nationwide reach, these ten dealers represent the best in the U.S. market today.
By focusing on coin dealerships, rare coins, precious metal investments, coin appraisals, gold coins, silver coins, numismatics, and trusted sellers, this guide equips you with everything needed to make informed decisions.
Remember: The key to successful collecting or investing lies not just in what you buy—but where you buy it.